one starry night header image of a night sky with the words one starry night

CoverGirl Ink It Eyeliner in Aquamarine

September 3rd 2013 1 minute to read





I wanted to love this eyeliner, I really did. It’s gorgeous swatched and REALLY set, took three tries with eye makeup remover to get it off my hand! However… and this is where it epically failed for me… it absolutely sucks on the waterline.

It barely applied, it was that sheer. I’m really disappointed.

I do think this would work well on the upper lashline but I generally use colors like these specifically for the waterline and sad to say, this didn’t work for me at all.

Price: $6-9 depending on sales
Where to Buy: Drugstores, Target

This post is over a year old which means the content may be outdated or no longer accurate.



I only got four hours of broken-up sleep last night. I’ve never been good at napping. I’m just left in this exhausted awake state of being.


Happy/Blessed Beltane, everyone!

Playing Catch-Up

I am pretty sure the last two weeks are catching up because I am beyond exhausted today. Trying to get caught up with the online world.

I Redesigned, Again

I redesigned OSN. It looks best at higher screen resolutions. That’s where you get all of the fancy effects. It’s fine on mobile but absolutely shines on a computer. Hopefully, everything works across the board. I tried to make the homepage an actual one, harkening back to the olden days of blogging.


Get weekly posts & snippets!
And get access to the OSN Freebie Library

view OSN Weekly archive

Recent Jams

That’s a bummer b/c it’s such a fun/pretty color.

RIGHT?! I was so happy when I bought it and then I swatched it… loved. Actually went to USE it? Epic fail.

kristen @ glambunctious

That’s too bad because the color is so poppin’!!

Reply to kristen @ glambunctious

I KNOW! It’s irritating. If it was a darker color I’d just use it on my top lash line but I bought it specifically for my waterline. Meh.

Amanda Jillian

That color is awesome too bad it sucks on the waterline.

Reply to Amanda Jillian

I’m so cranky about it. It would have been absolutely perfect if it just worked on the waterline.

Amanda Jillian

Yup I understand the crankiness

Reply to Amanda Jillian

So sad it didn’t last on your water line. I’m still on the search .for my HG liner looks like this won’t be it!

Yeah, it really made me sad that it just didn’t work on my waterline at all! I’m hoping I can find a bright blue shade that DOES work on the waterline soon.

Leave a Comment

Thank you for your comment!
Please Read the Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

- Previous
Newer -