Not only am I going to list all the eyeshadows I have BUT I am going to show photos of them as well. The list is going to be by brand and the photos will be in no particular order so if you see a color you want the name of, let me know. The photos really aren’t my best but considering the volume (and I was too lazy to do more than one basic photo of each), I’m sure we can let my normal high standards go here.

I’d love to see/hear about YOUR eyeshadow collection. I’d also find it awesome if you would share any of your favorite beauty/cosmetic blogs!


  • Urban Decay – Naked
  • Urban Decay – Mariposa
  • Too Faced – Natural Eye
  • Too Faced – Eye Love
  • Too Faced – Fantasy Island Duo
  • Kat Von D – Poetica
  • Maybelline – Green with Envy
  • Maybelline – Amethyst Smokes
  • Sonia Kashuk – ShowStoppers 01
  • Clinique – Beach Plum
  • Loreal – Platinum

  • lucky green
  • deep damson
  • plum dressing
  • cranberry
  • twinks
  • swimming
  • seedy pearl
  • bitter
  • crystal
  • star violet
  • pink freeze
  • fig.1
  • nocturnelle
  • vibrant grape
  • hepcat
  • shadowy lady
  • smut
  • satellite dreams
  • stars ‘n rockets
  • creme de violet
  • blackberry
  • shale
  • sketch
  • trax
  • scene
  • electric eel
  • groundwork
  • painterly
  • deep truth
  • contrast
  • carbon
  • motif
  • electra
  • knight divine
  • tilt
  • steamy
  • humid
  • juxt
  • gorgeous gold
  • goldmine
  • expensive pink
  • vex
  • satin taupe
  • haux
  • vanilla
  • retro-speck
  • all that glitters
  • vapour
  • nylon
  • ricepaper
  • white frost
  • phloof
  • shroom
  • dazzle-light
  • mylar
  • deep blue green pigment
  • heritage rouge pigment
  • old gold pigment

Benefit Creaseless Cream

  • tidal rave
  • purple snap
  • skinny jeans
  • tattle tale
Makeup Forever

  • star powder – turquoise
  • #83
  • #92
Urban Decay

  • vert
  • peace
  • goddess
  • mildew


  • wearable stone – dark
  • wearable stone – medium
  • wearable stone – light
  • passionate plum
  • soiree
  • foliage
  • envy
  • water lily
  • gilded quartz
  • masquerade
  • ice queen
  • sun goddess

  • pumpkinfire
  • jaguar
  • sleepy hollow
  • freya
  • herbivore
  • hypercool
  • warrior-mage
  • griffonrider
  • platinum

The Photos

Renèe B.
posted on November 18th 2011 at 12:35PM CDT

I had to gasp when I saw your “Naked” palette. Gunmetal looks completely untouched on yours, whereas on mine, it’s my absolutely favorite color, and I use it all the time. LOL!

Nice collection, Sarah!

posted on November 18th 2011 at 12:39PM CDT

I believe Gunmetal is one of my sister’s favorites too!

I just have SO MUCH it’s hard to make a dent in anything LOL!

posted on November 18th 2011 at 1:21PM CDT

There is a 4 month waiting list in Canada for the Naked pallet, so I’m quite jealous that you own it.

Also, do you use primer and if so which do you prefer? I have an Elizabeth Arden one that I LOVE but I bought some Urban Decay primer potion and I don’t really like it…

posted on November 18th 2011 at 1:23PM CDT

I got mine at Ulta, I would suggest stalking the Urban Decay site and Sephora site for Naked!

I use UDPP (Urban Decay Primer Potion) the most. I prefer Original and Sin.

I also like to use MAC Painterly Paint Pot or Benefit’s Creaseless Cream Eyeshadow in Tattle Tale for a primer too.

Jennifer Tait
posted on November 18th 2011 at 1:52PM CDT

If you are talking eye primer I love Laura Mercier. It is fantastic and lasts forever. I even just throw it on and mascara and go. Great texture too.

Jennifer Tait
posted on November 18th 2011 at 1:54PM CDT

Have you tried any Nars? I love their stuff and they have great colors. There is just to much fun makeup out there. I use to work at the Origins counter and miss it. I really miss the gratis and being there so often so I could peruse the other counters.

posted on November 18th 2011 at 8:05PM CDT

Yep! I love NARS lip and face products, don’t have any eyeshadows (yet).

LOL omg Origins had this gumball… it was the best gum EVER.

Jodi Hall
posted on November 18th 2011 at 2:58PM CDT

I have heard good things about the urban decay naked pallet.. is it worth it?

posted on November 18th 2011 at 8:06PM CDT

Oh yes! Not only are the shadows pigmented but they blend VERY well. Also the range of colors is fantastic basically from a “nude” look to a super dramatic smoky eye.

posted on November 18th 2011 at 6:00PM CDT

*gasp* Seriously. Your photography of these shades is impeccable, those are probably the best shots I’ve ever seen of Fyrinnae’s shades. It shows how truly complex they can be, and I love that. Umm, my name is Nicole and I am a Fyrinnae addict. Well, I already have long admired your photograpy, though.
PS Since I do lurk more than comment, I also wanted to tell you how much I always love your layouts.

posted on November 18th 2011 at 8:10PM CDT

I really need to post some macro shots of the Fyrinnae because the colors are AMAZING. I really need to order more. I only wish the shipping time wasn’t a month lol!

posted on November 18th 2011 at 9:42PM CDT

OMG, I want to come and play dress-up at your house! This is fantastic.

I’m normally not that much of an eyeshadow-wearer, but if I had a collection like this, I think I’d be playing with it each and every day.

posted on November 19th 2011 at 3:44PM CDT


posted on November 18th 2011 at 10:12PM CDT

Wow. I have TOTAL makeup envy. :) I have one palatte of Tarte eyeshadow, but I don’t even really know how to wear it.

posted on November 19th 2011 at 3:45PM CDT

OH which palette do you have?